A Different Future Is Possible
April 21, 2025
Right now, everything is geared towards turning nature into money and we are running out of nature.
By Phillip Meintzer
Read the PDF version here.
Living in Alberta, it seems like we are constantly bombarded by claims that the continued extraction of natural resources — typically oil and gas — is necessary to maintain some notion of the “good life.” Recent ad campaigns from both the Alberta government and Cenovus further emphasize this narrative by attempting to paint a picture of life without fossil fuels as dark, cold, and expensive.
These institutions want us to believe that a reduced standard of living is the only possible future in a world without further extraction, despite a growing body of evidence that suggests otherwise. But if we want to build an alternative future for this province and the people who live here, it can be helpful to imagine what that future may look like if we decide to take the path of least extraction.
Alberta’s settler colonial history may have been propelled by resource extraction, but that wasn’t always the case. The first oil well to be drilled in what is now Alberta (formerly the Northwest Territories) wasn’t until 1902, and the first commercial oilsands mine wasn’t until 1967. Our history with oil and gas is barely more than 120 years old, yet before colonization, Indigenous Peoples lived on this land for millennia in relative harmony with the natural world. Things weren’t always this way, and things don’t have to stay this way forever.
It’s important to recognize that humans, like other species, will always use nature in some way to meet our needs. However, our relationship with nature can be more or less sustainable depending on the economic system. Right now, everything is geared towards turning nature into money and we are running out of nature. That’s why sustainability is only possible if we can respect that the Earth has ecological limits and that all human activities need to equitably meet our needs without stepping beyond those boundaries.
A recent study published by Jason Hickel and Dylan Sullivan found that we could provide decent living standards for 8.5 billion people (more than Earth’s current population) using only 30 percent of our current resource and energy consumption if we shifted away from profit growth and toward a needs-base economy. Decent living standards would include universal access to nutritious food, modern housing, public education, internet, and healthcare, among other essentials.
This research demonstrates that the problem here isn’t a lack of resources. Hickel and Sullivan showed that we are wasting 70 percent of our energy and resources while many are still struggling to feed themselves and find secure housing. We have more than enough to meet everyone’s needs, and we certainly don’t need to expand our extractive footprint. The real problem is how those resources are distributed and whether people have access to the things they need to survive. Meeting human needs and protecting the environment must go hand in hand.
Let’s use the problem of oil and gas cleanup in Alberta as an example. The cleanup and reclamation costs of oil and gas disturbance in Alberta might be as high as $230 billion according to internal estimates from the Alberta Energy Regulator. Doing some quick math, if we divide $230 billion by a reasonable salary of $80,000 per year, that could employ roughly 290,000 Albertans across 10 years’ worth of cleanup work.
By contrast, there are around 130,000 people employed by the oil and gas industry in Alberta today. That’s less than half of the people we could employ for cleanup and restoration work. Reclaiming ecosystems could be a sensible way to provide good-paying jobs for more workers while repairing the harms caused by extraction — a win for people and a win for the environment.
Unfortunately, funding restoration work is only possible if the Alberta government and the Alberta Energy Regulator collect the money companies owe to the province to cover cleanup costs, which they are refusing to do. Focusing on the oilsands specifically, Alberta has only collected $912 million — less than one percent — towards $130 billion in estimated cleanup costs.
While this may be an oversimplification, I think it’s illustrative of the opportunities available to pursue alternative economies that prioritize the protection of Alberta’s landscape, without negatively impacting working people and their ability to support themselves. Expanding oil and gas production isn’t the only path forward for Alberta. We have other options, like renewable energy, if only our leaders weren’t held captive by corporate interests.
In response to the recently announced emissions cap for the oil and gas industry, the Alberta government launched a new ad campaign under the banner of “Scrap the Cap.” The premier claims that we will lose 150,000 jobs because of the emissions cap, but a conflicting report from Clean Energy Canada shows that a net-zero Canada would create 700,000 more energy jobs due to growth in renewables. Just because we lose jobs in one sector doesn’t mean we can’t create new jobs in sustainable industries and support workers through the transition[ with subsidized retraining programs or other incentives.
What’s more, evidence shows that switching to renewables also comes with the added benefit of reducing household costs. Research from the Canada Electricity Advisory Council found that switching to a net-zero electricity grid will save Canadian households an average of $1,500 per year. Renewables can provide more jobs, save people money, and help us reduce fossil fuel emissions. It’s a win across the board, and yet the Alberta government has decided to prop up the oil and gas industry by imposing restrictions on its main competitor. Meanwhile, other jurisdictions are leading the way.
When it comes to sustainable development, I’m constantly inspired by the work being done by the People’s Republic of China. While not without its flaws, China’s leadership on renewable energy shows what’s possible when you have the political will to take environmental issues seriously and dedicate the resources needed to deal with the problem.
In 2023 alone, China added more solar energy capacity than the United States and Canada have constructed in their entire history. This past July, it was reported that almost two-thirds of global wind and solar projects currently under construction were being built in China, more than the rest of the world combined. The same story showed that China was on track to reach 1,200 gigawatts of wind and solar capacity by the end of 2024, six years ahead of its 2030 target. Canada, by contrast, has installed roughly 22 gigawatts.
China’s move to renewables has been driven by a commitment by the Chinese government to build an “ecological civilization” as part of its political strategy back in 2007. The intent is to pursue economic development that occurs within planetary boundaries and ensures the harmonious existence between humanity and nature. As a result, China has become a world leader not only in renewable energy, but also the expansion of railways, the production of electric vehicles, and the reforestation of desert areas.
Alberta could be a world leader in renewables and sustainable development, but our government is choosing not to do so. This locks us into a future that’s worse for the environment, worse for working people, but great for fossil fuel companies
Despite what our leaders say, the alternative future is a brighter one. Evidence shows that we can protect the environment and meet human needs while using less resources, spending less money, and maybe even having more free time for ourselves. Even the United Nations recently stated that: “sustainable wellbeing for all cannot be achieved by an economic system that focuses solely on economic growth.” The path of least extraction is open to us, but it will take a massive, organized, and sustained effort on behalf of all of us to force our leaders to change ways. A greener future awaits us if we are ready to demand it.
How my time studying lemurs — and the challenges that came with it — shaped me as a conservation specialist
It was during my second — and last time — being in Madagascar that I climbed through wind-torn jungle trees after a cyclone had hit just days before. As I carefully picked which branch to grab next, it dawned on me how much climate change will impact the future of many species-at-risk.
I haven’t always been a conservation specialist.
Before setting my roots at Alberta Wilderness Association, I spent 10 years in and out of Madagascar as part of my master’s and PhD work.
Since I began my research as a graduate student at the University of Calgary, I have focused on understanding how different types of disturbance, mainly caused by humans, impact lemur communities in southeast Madagascar. Through both my master’s and now my PhD research, working in a highly disturbed ecosystem has shaped me as an ecologist, allowing me to analyze the complexities of ecosystems and the intricate ways species respond to environmental change.
Setting the scene
My research is based in Madagascar, an island country in the Indian Ocean, off the east coast of Africa. It has about 30 million people, with over 80 percent living below the poverty line of $2.15 USD per person per day. Lemurs are the endemic primates of Madagascar, meaning that the over 110 species described so far originated on the island and are found nowhere else in the world. Sadly, at least 17 species have gone extinct in the last 1,000 years due to human activities, and the remaining species are among the most threatened mammals in the world.
It is estimated that the ancestor of most modern lemur species arrived on the island around 65 million years ago. At that time, the island had relatively few mammal species, allowing lemurs’ ancestors to evolve into a wide variety of species in a process called adaptive radiation. This evolutionary path has produced extraordinary diversity: for example, the extinct Archaeoindris fontoynontii (there isn’t even a common name for this species!) was roughly the size of a gorilla, weighing around 160 kg, while the tiniest living lemur, Madame Berthe’s mouse lemur, weighs just 33 grams. Today, lemurs come in all shapes and sizes, from the child-sized Indri to the tiny mouse lemurs. Some have evolved remarkable traits, like the aye-aye’s ever-growing rodent-like teeth or the bamboo lemurs’ ability to consume cyanide-containing bamboo daily without harm.
Madagascar is a global biodiversity hotspot, home to an incredible number of endemic plants and animals. Unfortunately, much of its forest cover has been lost, pushing many species toward extinction. Most of my research has taken place in the southeast of Madagascar, on the forest fragments near the Kianjavato commune. Over the last 70 years, this area has lost around 90 percent of its original forest cover, and the forests that remain are home to nine species of lemurs, each with unique characteristics. Four species are nocturnal, four are cathemeral (active during both day and night), and one is diurnal. Among these species is one of the smallest lemurs, Jolly’s mouse lemur, as well as the Greater bamboo lemur — one of the few animals capable of surviving on cyanide-rich bamboo.
Trip one
In 2016, during my first trip to Madagascar for my master’s research, I spent six months in the field collecting data on lemur abundance and diversity. My goal was to understand how human disturbances affect lemur presence and abundance: do areas with more disturbance have fewer individuals and fewer species? And conversely, do areas with less disturbance support more individuals and more species?
My research involved daily hikes through hilly forests to conduct lemur surveys. My team included four local technicians from Kianjavato and a Malagasy master’s student. Together, we surveyed lemurs using 500-metre-long transects. These are straight paths through the forest created by researchers and technicians using a GPS unit and tape measures to systematically record wildlife observations. Over my six months, we repeatedly walked 35 transects across five forest fragments. Each day, we would travel to one of these fragments and walk two or three transects, scanning the treetops for lemurs. Since some species are nocturnal, we conducted surveys both during the day and at night.
At first glance, this might sound like a peaceful nature walk, but it was far from it! First, this is a tropical forest, so it was hot and humid. Second, the terrain was extremely hilly, making every survey a serious workout. Third, Kianjavato only has one road, and the villages have been built along it. Over time, deforestation has expanded outward from the road as people clear land for agriculture and other uses. As a result, most forest fragments are now far from the road, making access difficult. Surveying lemurs wasn’t just about walking 500 metres on a transect; it also meant hiking up to 10 kilometres just to reach the site — climbing steep hills, crossing multiple creeks, and then doing it all again on the way back. And, of course, we had to repeat this day after day, for six months, often working both day and night! It was exhausting work, and we didn’t always see lemurs on the surveys, but just being in the forest where they live, listening to the sounds of nature, and spotting other wildlife was something truly special.
Each survey lasted at least 30 minutes, longer if lemurs were detected. When we spotted a lemur, we recorded the species, group size, tree species, height in the canopy, and other relevant data. Once the day surveys were completed, we hiked back to the road to catch a ride to the field station. In six months of data collection, we observed eight of the nine species, only missing the elusive aye-aye.
In Kianjavato, I lived at the Kianjavato Ahmanson Field Station (KAFS), ran by the Madagascar Biodiversity Partnership, a local NGO. In 2016, accommodation was basic — there was no running water or electricity, though solar panels allowed us to charge equipment. We slept in tents inside huts and shared a latrine. By 2019, a rainwater-operated toilet had been installed, and by 2022, multiple toilets were available throughout the field site.
With my master’s research, I provided insights into lemur communities in disturbed forests, reinforcing my interest in conservation and the urgent need to study threatened species. Building on this foundation, my PhD research shifted to using camera traps instead of transects, allowing for a broader and less invasive method of monitoring wildlife. I also expanded my study area to include Ranomafana National Park (RNP), a protected area about 70 kilometres west of Kianjavato, to compare lemur communities in degraded and intact forests.
Trip two
In 2019, I spent four months in Madagascar testing a camera trap network with a master’s student. Camera trapping has long been used in wildlife research, but most studies have focused on terrestrial species. However, the lemurs I study in Kianjavato spend most of their lives in the trees, making ground-based cameras ineffective for studying them. In recent years, researchers in tropical forests worldwide have adapted camera trap technology for use in the canopy, allowing for better monitoring of arboreal mammals and birds.
Our goal was to test whether camera traps placed high in the trees could effectively record the nine lemur species in the area. Our daily routine was similar to line transect work — wake up, eat breakfast, hike to our destination. However, camera trapping required much heavier backpacks filled with tree-climbing gear, cameras, batteries, and climbing ropes. Once we reached the desired location, we selected a tree, conducted a risk assessment, and set up the climbing rope. After climbing around eight metres, we installed a camera up on the tree, placed another at ground level, and conducted vegetation and disturbance surveys before moving to the next location.
By the end of the season, we were so happy with the results — our cameras had captured all nine lemur species, showing that arboreal camera trapping was more effective than line transects.
A delayed return, and the cyclones
I planned to return to Madagascar in 2020, but the COVID-19 pandemic delayed my fieldwork until 2022. In January 2022, I traveled back with two other graduate students and a research assistant from the University of Calgary. After a 28-hour journey to Madagascar’s capital, Antananarivo, we underwent COVID-19 testing and isolation before meeting our Malagasy research assistants and heading to Kianjavato.
Although this was my third trip to Madagascar, it was the first time I was there during the main part of the rainy season, so I anticipated some challenges. However, I was not expecting just how different this field season would be. My research assistant, Mirana, and I met our team of eight local technicians and began installing camera traps on Jan. 24, just like I had done in 2019.
By early February, reports emerged of an approaching category 3 cyclone, Batsirai. On Feb. 4, after only nine days of work, we packed our tents and evacuated to Centre ValBio (CVB), a field station located in RNP.
At CVB, other graduate researchers had also gathered to wait out the storm. We closely monitored weather updates, hoping Batsirai would weaken or change course. Unfortunately, on Feb. 5, it made landfall with sustained winds of 165 kilometres per hour and gusts up to 230 kilometres per hour. We had to stay at CVB for five days until the roads were cleared of landslides and fallen trees.
We returned to KAFS, witnessing widespread devastation. Many community members lost their homes and given that typical houses in the area are made from wood with woven palm leaves for roofs, the destruction was severe. KAFS sustained mainly vegetation damage, but the forest fragments were unrecognizable. When we resumed work on Feb.10, navigating the landscape was far more challenging due to fallen trees and thick debris. Even though I considered myself an experienced hiker, I got heat exhaustion on my first day back in the forest after a pretty easy hike.
Tree climbing became even riskier — many trees that remained standing were unstable or had broken branches, so I had to carefully assess each tree before climbing. The team and I worked for a few more days, and I spent some days teaching them tree climbing before heading back to CVB on Feb. 14 for a tree-climbing workshop I was leading. Over five days, I trained local technicians on tree climbing techniques to install camera traps for a long-term research project in RNP. This project is also part of my PhD and will help us compare lemur responses to disturbances in protected versus unprotected areas.
On Feb. 20, Mirana and I returned to KAFS, only to face yet another evacuation —this time due to Cyclone Emnati, a category 4 storm heading our way. We were evacuated again the next day, and Emnati made landfall on the day after. Fortunately, by the time it reached Madagascar, it had weakened to a category 1 cyclone. This time, we only had to stay at CVB for four days. The next day, we were back in the field, retrieving the cameras we had managed to set before the first cyclone struck. We also took the opportunity to assess cyclone-related disturbances in the vegetation, recording the number of fallen trees, broken trunks, and snapped branches across our survey plots.
Thankfully, the remainder of my time in Madagascar was uneventful — aside from multiple bouts of what felt like heat exhaustion. The team adapted quickly to the disruptions, and we successfully recovered all our cameras while conducting additional vegetation surveys.
Despite the challenges posed by the cyclones — including fallen trees that had cameras mounted on them — the cameras still managed to capture all nine lemur species that inhabit the Kianjavato forests. Our vegetation surveys revealed that at least 77 percent of the trees had suffered substantial damage, ranging from fallen leaves and broken branches to fully uprooted trees.
This experience deeply shaped me as a field ecologist. It gave me a firsthand look at the potential effects of climate change — not just on wildlife but also on the human communities that depend on these forests. Cyclones are not new to Madagascar, but climate change is expected to increase both their frequency and intensity, placing additional pressure on local communities that rely on forest resources, as well as on the already fragile ecosystems and the wildlife that depend on them.
My work in Madagascar over the past 10 years has taught me far more than the ecological interactions between animals and vegetation or how lemurs respond to disturbances. It has shaped me as both a scientist and a conservation advocate. The impacts of climate change, while varying across the globe, are inevitable. How we respond will determine the future of both people and wildlife.
Joining AWA is an exciting new chapter in my career. I am passionate about conservation and eager to bring my expertise to this incredible organization, which has been working to protect Alberta’s wilderness for 60 years. I look forward to contributing to AWA’s efforts to protect our province’s wilderness and collaborating with colleagues, other ENGOs, and the broader community in this mission.